TECHNOLOGY EXPLAINER
Cell Culture Media
— a type-by-type guide to the liquid formulations cells live in
A culture medium is the liquid in which cells are grown. It began in the 1950s as “the bare minimum of nutrients” and has spent 70 years moving towards less serum and fully identified ingredients. There are more types than anyone could count, varying with the purpose, the cell and the way it is cultured. Drawing on original papers and regulators' documents, this article sorts them along six axes.

- What a culture medium is, in three points
- What goes into it: components and their roles
- The family tree of basal media, 1950 to 1980
- Our calculation: bicarbonate and CO2
- How serum is handled: five stages
- A materials engineer's view (1): albumin was working as an adsorbent
- Media by purpose: antibodies, viral vectors, insect cells, T cells, iPS cells, differentiation, organoids
- The types of culture media at a glance
- By culture mode: feed media and perfusion media
- A materials engineer's view (2): adding ingredients that will not dissolve or will not last
- Format and manufacture: powder, liquid, concentrate, and sterile filtration
- Media for cultivated meat: the cost wall
- A materials engineer's view (3): a pharmaceutical formulation at a food price
- Open problems, and what this article could not confirm
- Glossary / References / Claim-to-source audit
Sourced = stated in published material or a paper (link given)
Our calculation = a value this article derived from assumptions it states
Not yet confirmed = a plan, an outlook or a research-stage result with no confirmed practical track record
Structural readings and materials-design interpretations are marked separately as Commentary.
This article explains technology. It is not medical advice and does not recommend any product.
1. What a culture medium is, in three points
A culture medium is the liquid that cells sit in so that they can survive, multiply and do their work outside the body. Inside the body, blood and tissue fluid deliver nutrients, salts and hormones. The easiest way to think of a medium is as an artificial formulation that recreates that supply (our commentary).
- The backbone: the foundation is a “basal medium”: water with inorganic salts, sugar, amino acids, vitamins and a buffer dissolved in it. In 1955 Harry Eagle identified the minimum set of components needed by mouse L cells and human HeLa cells, and this is regarded as the starting point for many of today's basal mediaSourced
- What gets added: most cells will not grow on a basal medium alone. The gap used to be filled by adding serum (fetal bovine serum and the like), but because serum is undefined and varies widely from lot to lot, it has increasingly been replaced by serum-free media that add the necessary factors one by oneSourced
- Why there are so many types: the best formulation differs with the cell (antibody-producing CHO cells, iPS cells, T cells, insect cells and so on), with the goal (expanding cells, differentiating them, or making them produce something) and with the culture mode (batch, fed-batch or perfusion) (our commentary)
The history of culture media is the history of replacing a liquid of unknown content (serum) with a formulation whose content is known. The E8 medium reported in 2011 showed that human iPS cells could be cultured by adding just seven components to a basal mediumSourced. In materials terms, it is a shift from a natural mixture to a formulation of defined composition.
2. What goes into it: components and their roles
First, split the contents of a medium into “the base” (the basal medium) and “what is added for the purpose”.
| Component | Role | What the literature says, and caveats |
|---|---|---|
| Amino acids | Building blocks of protein. The “essential amino acids” that cells cannot make for themselves must be supplied | Eagle's BME consists of 13 amino acids and 8 vitaminsSourced. Glutamine is said to be needed in about 3 to 40 times the amount of the other amino acidsSourced |
| Sugar (glucose) | Energy source | DMEM raised glucose to 25 mmol/L for cells with high demandSourced. 25 mmol/L is about 4.5 g/LOur calculation |
| Vitamins | Raw material for the coenzymes that help enzyme reactions | α-MEM adds ascorbic acid, biotin, cyanocobalamin and othersSourced |
| Inorganic salts | Balance of osmolality and electrolytes | RPMI-1640 is characterised by low calcium and magnesium and high phosphateSourced |
| Buffer (bicarbonate/CO2) | Holds the pH, working as a pair with the CO2 in the incubator | The bicarbonate concentration sets the CO2 level required (Section 4)Sourced |
| Buffer (HEPES) | Makes it easier to hold the pH outside a CO2 incubator | Good and colleagues reported “hydrogen ion buffers for biological research” in 1966Sourced. There are reports that media containing HEPES generate more hydrogen peroxide and other cytotoxic substances when exposed to visible lightSourced |
| Growth factors and cytokines | “Signals” for growth and differentiation | E8 medium contains FGF2 at 100 µg/L and TGFβ1 at 2 µg/LSourced |
| Insulin, transferrin, selenium (ITS) | Insulin for sugar uptake, transferrin for carrying iron, selenium for antioxidant enzymes | Because so many cells need all three, they are sold together as ITSSourced |
| Albumin | Carrier for lipids and other molecules; protection | Commercial albumin contains traces of more than 100 serum proteins and can bind phthalates (plasticisers) and endotoxinsSourced (Section 6) |
| Trace elements | Active centres of enzymes and the like | Using Ham's F-12 protein-free with cells other than CHO is said to require modifications such as lowering the zinc concentrationSourced |
| pH indicator (phenol red) | Shows pH changes by colour | At the concentrations found in media (15 to 45 µM) it acts as a weak oestrogenSourced. 15 to 45 µM is about 5.3 to 16 mg/LOur calculation |
Sources for the “What the literature says” column: Yao and Asayama [Ref. 9], Eagle [Ref. 1], Good et al. [Ref. 32], Chen et al. [Ref. 14], Berthois et al. [Ref. 31]. The “Role” column is this article's general explanation. Conversions are our calculation (glucose 180.16 g/mol, phenol red 354.4 g/mol).
3. The family tree of basal media, 1950 to 1980
Many of the basal media in use today were born in the thirty years or so between 1950 and 1980. Each was created to grow a particular kind of cell.
| Basal medium | Developers, original paper (year) | Original target | Features of the formulation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medium 199 | Morgan, Morton and Parker (1950) | Culturing chick embryo cells without protein | Amino acids, vitamins (including fat-soluble ones), nucleic acid precursors and more. A highly complex formulation that included even the components theory said might be needed. Widely used for organ culture |
| BME (Eagle's Basal Medium) | Eagle (1955) | Mouse L cells, human HeLa cells | The bare minimum. 13 amino acids and 8 vitamins. Its simplicity makes it a poor fit for cells that need many components |
| MEM (Eagle's Minimum Essential Medium) | Eagle (1959) | An improvement on BME | Most amino acids at about twice the BME level. Non-essential amino acids are sometimes added to spare the cells the work of making them |
| DMEM (Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium) | Dulbecco and Freeman (1959) | Mouse embryo cells, used to study plaque formation by polyoma virus | Amino acids and vitamins at about four times the BME level. The version that spread later added glycine, serine, iron and pyruvate and raised glucose to 25 mmol/L |
| L-15 (Leibovitz) | Leibovitz (1963) | Culture in free gas exchange with the atmosphere | Buffered with phosphate and basic amino acids rather than bicarbonate, so the pH holds without a CO2 incubator. The energy source is pyruvate (and galactose) rather than glucose |
| Ham's F-12 | Ham (1965) | Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells | Often cited as “the world's first chemically defined medium”. A single CHO cell could form a colony without protein. Uses linoleic acid and putrescine in place of serum proteins |
| RPMI-1640 | Moore, Gerner and Franklin (1967) | Long-term culture of human peripheral blood leukocytes (lymphocytes) | Widely used for lymphocytes, leukocytes and hybridomas. Low in calcium and magnesium, high in phosphate |
| α-MEM | Stanners, Eliceiri and Green (1971) | Research on mouse-hamster hybrid cells | MEM plus non-essential amino acids, vitamins (ascorbic acid, biotin, cyanocobalamin), pyruvate, lipoic acid and nucleosides |
| IMDM (Iscove's Modified Dulbecco's Medium) | Iscove and Melchers (1978) | Mouse B cells that respond to lipopolysaccharide | A richer version of DMEM. Called “M-DMEM” in the original paper, it adds amino acids, vitamin B12, biotin, selenite, pyruvate and more. Serum could be replaced entirely by albumin, transferrin and soybean lipid |
| DMEM/F-12 | Barnes and Sato (1980) and others | Serum-free culture of many kinds of cell | A 50:50 mix of the component-rich F-12 and the nutrient-dense DMEM. The most widely used basal medium for serum-free culture |
All Sourced. Developers and years follow each original paper [Refs. 1 to 8, 10 and 11]; targets and features follow the review by Yao and Asayama [Ref. 9]; details of IMDM follow the original paper by Iscove and colleagues [Ref. 7]. The only original paper whose full text this article could read was the IMDM paper (Iscove et al.); the others were checked against their PubMed records and the review.
4. Our calculation: bicarbonate and CO2
Many media hold their pH through the combination of sodium hydrogen carbonate (bicarbonate) and the CO2 in the incubator. Using the Henderson–Hasselbalch equation, the review by Yao and Asayama shows that MEM (26 mmol/L bicarbonate) needs 5% CO2, Ham's F-12 (14 mmol/L) needs 2%, and DMEM (44 mmol/L) needs 10%Sourced. It adds that these are theoretical values, and in practice it is better to measure the pH after equilibration and fine-tune the CO2 levelSourced.
This article checks the numbers with the same equationOur calculation.
- Equation: pH = 6.1 + log10([HCO3⁻] / (0.03 × pCO2)), with [HCO3⁻] in mmol/L and pCO2 in mmHg
- Assumptions: target pH 7.4, atmospheric pressure 760 mmHg, water vapour pressure ignored, temperature dependence of the coefficients ignored
- Working: required pCO2 = [HCO3⁻] / (0.03 × 10^1.3) = [HCO3⁻] / 0.599
- MEM: 26 / 0.599 = 43.4 mmHg; 43.4 / 760 = about 5.7%
- F-12: 14 / 0.599 = 23.4 mmHg; about 3.1%
- DMEM: 44 / 0.599 = 73.5 mmHg; about 9.7%
Assumptions and limits: for F-12 the result differs from the review's value (the review gives 5%, 2% and 10%). The answer shifts with the target pH and with how the coefficient and pressure are treated. What matters is not the exact figure but the proportionality: the more bicarbonate a medium contains, the more CO2 it needs. Run DMEM at 5% CO2 and the same equation gives a pH of about 7.7Our calculation.
5. How serum is handled: five stages
“Serum-free”, “animal-component free”, “xeno-free”, “chemically defined”: media catalogues are full of these labels. Each one describes how far the medium has moved away from serum, a liquid whose content nobody fully knows.
What serum was doing
The review by Yao and Asayama summarises the functions of fetal bovine serum (FBS) as followsSourced.
- A source of amino acids, proteins, vitamins, sugars, lipids, hormones, growth factors, inorganic salts and trace elements
- Raising the pH buffering capacity of the medium
- Reducing shear stress (physical damage) from pipetting and stirring
- Changing the state of the culture surface so that adherent cells attach and grow more readily
Why people still want to stop using it
| Reason | What the primary sources say |
|---|---|
| Lot-to-lot variation | Serum is undefined in composition and varies widely between lots (Yao and Asayama)Sourced |
| Risk of infectious agents | The risk of contamination by viruses and other agents is high (Yao and Asayama)Sourced. On bovine viral diarrhoea virus (BVDV), the EMA guideline states that its presence cannot be completely avoided, except in serum from specific controlled herds or from cattle in BVDV-free regions, and requires testing before useSourced |
| Ruminant origin | The EMA guideline starts from the position of the guidance on TSEs (transmissible spongiform encephalopathies) that where there is a choice between ruminant and non-ruminant material, non-ruminant material is preferredSourced |
| Purification burden | In biopharmaceutical manufacturing, serum makes downstream purification of the product harder (Yao and Asayama)Sourced |
| Reproducibility, ethics, supply | FBS brings problems of data quality and reproducibility, animal-welfare concerns and recent cases of fraudulent labelling, and the development of alternatives and serum-free media is attracting attention worldwide (van der Valk et al.)Sourced |
Sources: Yao and Asayama [Ref. 9], EMA guideline EMA/CHMP/BWP/457920/2012 rev 1 [Ref. 13], van der Valk et al. [Ref. 12]. The EMA guideline was adopted on 30 May 2013 and came into effect on 1 December 2013.
On inactivating viruses in serum, the EMA guideline notes that gamma irradiation is the most commonly used method, while also accepting other validated methodsSourced. Whether a process keeps serum or moves away from it, the underlying question is the same: how do you guarantee what is in a liquid raw material? (our commentary)
6. A materials engineer's view (1): albumin was working as an adsorbent
For a long time, serum-free media replaced serum with high concentrations of albumin (bovine serum albumin, BSA, and the like). Yet in 2011 Chen and colleagues, reporting E8 medium, made the following point.
Lot-to-lot variation in albumin is especially problematic, because its concentration is far higher than that of the other proteins in the medium and because it binds lipids and other impurities (our paraphrase)Sourced.
They went on to find that human ES cells survive without BSA provided that β-mercaptoethanol is removed at the same time, and concluded that the main role of BSA in TeSR medium is to protect the cells from the toxicity of β-mercaptoethanolSourced.
The review by Yao and Asayama likewise points out that commercial albumin contains traces of more than 100 serum proteins and can bind phthalates (common plasticisers) and endotoxinsSourced.
Put in materials terms, albumin can be read as having worked in the medium as an adsorbent that soaks up small hydrophobic molecules. That has two implications (our commentary).
- Remove the albumin, and whatever it used to adsorb now reaches the cells. Not only the toxicity of medium components, but also traces leaching from containers, tubing and filters may become more visible
- “Lot variation” in albumin is also variation in the impurities it carries. Quality depends not only on purity and origin but on what the albumin was holding when it shipped
For materials engineers who work with resins, plasticisers or wetted components, going serum-free means an era in which leachables from their own materials hit the cells with no cushion in between. It has the same root as the growing emphasis on leachables testing for single-use components (our commentary).
7. Media by purpose: antibodies, viral vectors, insect cells, T cells, iPS cells, differentiation, organoids
Starting from a basal medium, formulations branch according to which cell you are growing and what you want it to do. Below are representative examples that could be confirmed in primary sources.
(1) For producing antibodies and other proteins (CHO cells)
The review by Ritacco and colleagues describes how media for recombinant protein production in CHO cells moved from early formulations containing animal-derived and complex components to serum-free media and then chemically defined (CD) media, and then developed further towards optimising nutrient supply and limiting the build-up of waste products through fed-batch and perfusion cultureSourced. In 2015 a group from Chugai Pharmaceutical, noting that chemically defined media are currently used for fed-batch culture of antibody-producing CHO cells, reported an optimisation of feed mediaSourced.
(2) For producing viral vectors (HEK293 cells)
HEK293 cells, derived from human embryonic kidney, are widely used to manufacture the adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors used in gene therapy. In 2016 Grieger and colleagues reported adapting adherent HEK293 cells from a clinical master cell bank to animal-component-free suspension culture and producing AAV vectors in shake flasks and a bag-type bioreactorSourced. One of the items they optimised was the choice of a serum-free suspension medium that supports both cell growth and transfection (gene delivery)Sourced. In other words, a medium for growing cells and a medium for getting genes into them are asked to do different things (our commentary).
(3) For insect cells
Insect cells are used, among other things, for protein production with baculovirus. In 1962 Grace reported in Nature that he had established four cell strains from insect tissueSourced. In 1977 Vaughn and colleagues reported establishing two cell lines from pupal tissue of the fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda): one (IPLB-SF 21) in a medium supplemented with insect body fluid (haemolymph) and the other (IPLB-SF-1254) in a medium combining vertebrate serum with haemolymphSourced. Insect cell media come from a lineage separate from that of mammalian media (our commentary).
(4) For T cells, NK cells and other immune cells
Media for expanding T cells have included ones supplemented with human serum (the paper by Medvec and colleagues uses a human-serum medium as its comparator). In 2018 Medvec and colleagues reported developing a chemically defined medium that expands all T-cell subsets without human serumSourced. In a humanised mouse model, T cells expanded without serum controlled tumours for longerSourced. This is an experimental result in mice, however, and does not show any therapeutic effect in humans. For NK cell media, this article could not confirm original papers within the scope of its research, so they are not described separately.
(5) For maintaining pluripotent stem cells (ES and iPS cells)
| Medium | What the primary sources say |
|---|---|
| TeSR (Ludwig et al., 2006) | Ludwig and colleagues at the University of Wisconsin reported conditions in which human ES cells could be derived and cultured without feeder cells, using only recombinant or purified human-derived proteinsSourced. According to the later E8 paper, TeSR contained BSA, TGFβ, LiCl, GABA, pipecolic acid, lipids, trace elements, glutathione and moreSourced |
| mTeSR™1 | A product of STEMCELL Technologies. The company describes it as a cGMP, feeder-free maintenance medium for human ES and iPS cells, serum-free, and developed under licence to intellectual property of the WiCell Research InstituteSourced |
| E8 (Essential 8; Chen et al., 2011) | A chemically defined medium made by re-examining the TeSR components one at a time and adding just seven components to DMEM/F-12. Leaving out serum albumin is described as a major improvement. Vitronectin is used as the substrateSourced |
| StemFit™ (Nakagawa et al., 2014) | Joint research by Kyoto University CiRA, Osaka University and Ajinomoto. Combining StemFit, a completely xeno-free medium, with a recombinant laminin-511 E8 fragment, they reported stable long-term culture even when passaging as single dissociated cellsSourced |
| B8 (Kuo et al., 2020) | A medium whose components and concentrations were exhaustively optimised. Reagent cost is 3% of commercial media, mainly because FGF2, TGFβ3 and neuregulin 1 were produced in E. coli in the lab. The authors report maintenance for more than 100 passages and no need for weekend medium changesSourced |
Sources: Ludwig et al. [Refs. 15 and 16], STEMCELL Technologies product page [Ref. 17], Chen et al. [Ref. 14], Nakagawa et al. [Ref. 18], Kuo et al. [Ref. 35].
What Fig. 5 shows is that growth factors are indispensable even in minute amounts. TGFβ1 is present at 2 µg/L: two millionths of a gram in a litre. Trace proteins like this drive both the performance and the cost of a medium (Section 12) (our commentary).
(6) For inducing differentiation
Turning pluripotent stem cells into a specific cell type calls for a different medium. In 2014 Burridge and colleagues reported generating cardiomyocytes from human iPS cells in a chemically defined medium made of just three components: RPMI 1640, L-ascorbic acid 2-phosphate and rice-derived recombinant human albumin, obtaining cell sheets in which up to 95% of cells were positive for a cardiac markerSourced. For neurons, a well-known serum-free combination is “B27-supplemented Neurobasal”, reported by Brewer and colleagues in 1993Sourced. According to the review by Yao and Asayama, B-27 contains ITS plus progesterone, putrescine, triiodothyronine, fatty acids, vitamin E, BSA and glutathioneSourced. It is striking that RPMI-1640, a medium first reported in 1967, became the basal medium for cardiac differentiation in the 2010s (our commentary).
(7) For organoids
Organoid media (organoids being small organ-like structures that self-organise from stem cells) are built to recreate the signals of the body's stem-cell “home”, the niche. In 2009 Toshiro Sato and colleagues reported that a single Lgr5-positive stem cell from mouse small intestine could form an organoid with crypt-villus structuresSourced. According to a review by Clevers and colleagues, this culture used a growth-factor cocktail of EGF, the BMP inhibitor Noggin and R-spondin, within an extracellular matrixSourced. A 2011 report found that long-term culture of human small intestine and colon required the addition of Wnt3A, plus nicotinamide, an Alk inhibitor and a p38 inhibitorSourced. Organoids are covered in more detail in our explainer on organoids and spheroids.
8. The types of culture media at a glance
The table below brings everything so far together along six axes. The same medium can appear under more than one axis (E8, for instance, is both “for pluripotent stem cells” and “chemically defined”).
| Axis | Type | In a phrase | Examples and origins (primary sources) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basal medium | Minimal formulation | A starting point with only the essentials | BME (Eagle 1955), MEM (Eagle 1959) |
| Basal medium | Concentrated, nutrient-rich formulation | Richer, more, faster growth | DMEM (Dulbecco 1959), IMDM (Iscove 1978), α-MEM (Stanners 1971) |
| Basal medium | Formulation for a specific cell | Salt and component balance matched to the target cell | RPMI-1640 (Moore 1967, lymphocytes), Ham's F-12 (Ham 1965, CHO cells), 199 (Morgan 1950, chick embryo) |
| Basal medium | Formulation needing no CO2 | Holds pH in ordinary air | L-15 (Leibovitz 1963) |
| Basal medium | Mixed medium | Combines the strengths of two | DMEM/F-12 (50:50, the foundation for serum-free culture) |
| Serum handling | Serum-supplemented medium | Serum fills the gaps | Fetal bovine serum (FBS) and others. EMA guidance sets out controls for the quality and viral safety of bovine serum |
| Serum handling | Serum-free medium | Factors added one by one instead of serum | IMDM plus albumin, transferrin and soybean lipid (Iscove 1978); ITS supplementation |
| Serum handling | Animal-component free (ADCF) | No raw materials of animal origin | Animal-component-free suspension culture of HEK293 (Grieger 2016) |
| Serum handling | Xeno-free | No components from other species for human cells | StemFit (Nakagawa 2014) |
| Serum handling | Chemically defined | Every component and concentration specified | Ham's F-12 (often cited as “the world's first”), E8 (Chen 2011), three-component cardiac differentiation medium (Burridge 2014) |
| By purpose | For producing antibodies and other proteins | Keep CHO cells at high density and make them produce | Chemically defined medium plus feed media (Ritacco 2018, Kishishita 2015) |
| By purpose | For producing viral vectors | Support both growth and gene delivery | Serum-free suspension medium for HEK293 (Grieger 2016) |
| By purpose | For insect cells | A lineage separate from mammalian media | Grace (1962); establishment of Sf cell lines (Vaughn 1977) |
| By purpose | For T cells | Expand immune cells without human serum | Chemically defined T-cell medium (Medvec 2018) |
| By purpose | For maintaining pluripotent stem cells | Expand while keeping them undifferentiated | TeSR (Ludwig 2006), mTeSR™1, E8 (Chen 2011), StemFit (Nakagawa 2014), B8 (Kuo 2020) |
| By purpose | For inducing differentiation | Turn cells into the target type | Three-component RPMI 1640-based medium (Burridge 2014, cardiomyocytes); Neurobasal plus B27 (Brewer 1993, neurons) |
| By purpose | For organoids | Recreate the signals of the stem-cell niche | EGF, Noggin, R-spondin (Sato 2009); Wnt3A, nicotinamide and others added for human intestine (Sato 2011) |
| By culture mode | Basic medium (batch) | Grow on the starting medium alone | — (Section 9) |
| By culture mode | Feed medium (fed-batch) | Concentrated nutrients added partway through | Poorly soluble tyrosine added as peptides (Kishishita 2015) |
| By culture mode | Perfusion medium | Replaced continuously | “Push-to-low”, lowering the cell-specific perfusion rate (Konstantinov 2006) |
| Format | Powder, liquid, concentrate | Balancing shipping and storage against effort at the point of use | Consistency and scalability of preparing powder and liquid media are key issues (Ritacco 2018) |
| Format | Sterile filtration | Sterilising without heat | FDA guidance: 0.2 µm rated filters, validated with at least 10⁷ organisms per cm² |
| Other | For cultivated meat | Made in bulk at a food price | Beefy-9 (Stout 2022); cost analysis (Humbird 2021) |
All Sourced (see the reference list for each row's source). The “Axis” and “In a phrase” classifications, however, are this article's own framing, not an established industry classification.
9. By culture mode: feed media and perfusion media
Even for the same cell and the same goal, the way the medium is supplied changes the medium you need.
Feed media (fed-batch culture)
In fed-batch culture, concentrated nutrients (a feed medium) are added during the run. Kishishita and colleagues reported adding to the feed medium the amino acids that had been heavily consumed in control cultures, and controlling the additions so that waste products such as lactate and ammonia did not accumulate too farSourced. They also added poorly soluble tyrosine in the form of dipeptides and tripeptides to make it dissolve more readilySourced.
Perfusion media (perfusion culture)
In perfusion culture, the cells are kept in the vessel while fresh medium is continuously fed in and spent medium drawn off. In 2006 Konstantinov and colleagues introduced the “equivalent specific perfusion rate” as a common yardstick for comparing fed-batch and perfusion, and showed that the key to making perfusion economically competitive is to cut the dilution rate (how fast the medium is exchanged) sharply while keeping the cell density highSourced. They named this optimisation procedure “push-to-low”, a stepwise lowering of the specific perfusion rate, and reported raising the titre of an antibody against TNF several-foldSourced. A perfusion medium, in other words, has to be concentrated enough to support more cells with less liquid (our commentary).
10. A materials engineer's view (2): adding ingredients that will not dissolve or will not last
Feed media for fed-batch culture and perfusion media are media that you want to make concentrated. But some amino acids cannot be concentrated.
- Tyrosine does not dissolve well. Kishishita and colleagues reported raising its solubility by supplying it as dipeptides and tripeptidesSourced
- Glutamine falls apart. The review by Yao and Asayama notes that glutamine breaks down readily in the medium, producing ammonia, which is toxic to cells, and lists as remedies adding it just before use, or using the more stable L-alanyl-L-glutamine or glycyl-L-glutamineSourced
Both follow the same idea: rather than adding the target molecule as it is, add it in another form. Enzymes inside or on the surface of the cell cut it, and it is then used as the original amino acid. It is, in effect, a prodrug-style ingredient design (our commentary).
In materials work, converting a poorly soluble ingredient into a salt or derivative, or adding an ingredient that degrades in storage as a stable precursor, are familiar techniques. Pushed to its core, developing a medium is a formulation problem: keeping a high-concentration aqueous formulation from precipitating or degrading. pH, temperature, light (the case of HEPES generating hydrogen peroxide), shelf life: the evaluation axes look a lot like those used in developing paint or electrolyte formulations (our commentary).
11. Format and manufacture: powder, liquid, concentrate, and sterile filtration
Media are supplied as powder, as ready-to-use liquid or as concentrate. The review by Ritacco and colleagues identifies consistency and scalability in preparing powder and liquid media as key issues for industrial useSourced. Powder is light and easy to store, but the user has to dissolve it, adjust the pH and sterilise it. Liquid saves that effort, but it means shipping water, and the stability of the components during storage becomes an issue (our commentary).
- The challenge organism commonly used for 0.2 µm rated filters is Brevundimonas diminuta (ATCC 19146), which is small, with a mean diameter of 0.3 µmSourced
- Because a filter can contain pores larger than its nominal rating, it is usual to challenge it with at least 10⁷ organisms per cm² of effective filtration area and confirm that none pass throughSourced
- 0.22 µm and 0.2 µm are treated as interchangeable nominal pore-size ratingsSourced
- The guidance states explicitly that it does not address the removal of virusesSourced
In other words, a sterile-filtered medium is not the same thing as a virus-free medium. That is exactly why biological raw materials such as serum call for a separate measure such as gamma irradiation (Section 5) (our commentary).

12. Media for cultivated meat: the cost wall
Nowhere is the cost of media scrutinised more harshly than in cultivated meat. In a 2021 review, O'Neill and colleagues at UC Davis point out that therapeutic monoclonal antibodies, the largest industrial use of animal cell culture, sell for orders of magnitude more than meat, and that cultivated meat needs a medium that is food-grade, of minimal cost, able to control large-scale proliferation and differentiation, organoleptically acceptable and free of animal componentsSourced.
In 2021 Humbird assessed large-scale production of cultivated meat using the techno-economic methods of industrial fermentation and biopharmaceuticalsSourced. In a scenario of 100,000 tonnes a year (100 kTA), on the scale of the global market, he estimated production costs of US$37 per kg of wet cell mass for fed-batch culture and US$51 for perfusion, of which amino acids account for US$19/kg, growth factors US$3 to 4/kg and glucose about US$0.24/kgSourced. His conclusion is that the economics of such facilities are likely to stand in the way of an affordable food productNot yet confirmed.
Work on bringing costs down is under way. The B8 medium mentioned earlier cut reagent cost to 3% of commercial mediaSourced. In 2022 Stout and colleagues at Tufts University reported that “Beefy-9”, which is simply B8 plus one added component, recombinant albumin, expanded bovine muscle satellite cells over seven passages with an average doubling time of 39 hoursSourced. These are research-stage results, however, and within the scope of this article no record could be confirmed of their use in volume production of foodNot yet confirmed.
13. A materials engineer's view (3): a pharmaceutical formulation at a food price
Mention the cost of media and people tend to think of expensive proteins such as growth factors. Yet in Humbird's estimate, at a scale of 100,000 tonnes a year, amino acids are the largest item at US$19/kg, while growth factors come to only US$3 to 4/kgSourced. As shares, that is about 51% for amino acids and about 8 to 11% for growth factorsOur calculation.
The reason is that the estimate builds into its prices the relationship in which unit cost falls as production volume rises. Growth factors are assumed to fall sharply in price with mass production, but amino acids of purity high enough for pharmaceutical use are needed in huge quantities. Humbird examines the option of using soy hydrolysate to bring mixed amino acids down to around US$2/kg, and says further research is neededSourced.
One more thing stands out. The growth-factor concentrations Humbird assumed, insulin 19.4 mg/L, transferrin 10.7 mg/L, FGF 0.1 mg/L and TGF-β 0.002 mg/LSourced, match the E8 formulation shown in Fig. 5 (our cross-check). A formulation minimised for human iPS cells has become the starting point for a food cost estimate.
Seen through a materials engineer's eyes, media for cultivated meat come down to questions familiar from chemicals and food ingredients: how far can purity be lowered, and can hydrolysates of natural materials replace synthetic ones? Pharmaceutical media have spent 70 years moving towards “identifying everything”; cultivated meat can be read as taking on the reverse challenge: how much reproducibility can be kept with cheap raw materials that are not over-specified? (our commentary)
14. Open problems, and what this article could not confirm
(1) The terms are not consistently defined
“Serum-free”, “animal-component free”, “xeno-free” and “chemically defined” cover subtly different ground depending on the paper or company. Within the scope of this article, no official standard defining them consistently could be confirmed, so the five stages in Fig. 4 are presented as this article's own framing.
(2) The composition of most commercial media is not disclosed
Most commercial media for CHO cells, HEK293 cells, T cells and so on do not have published compositions. This article gives specific components only where the composition could be confirmed in an original paper (E8, the original form of IMDM, the three-component cardiac differentiation medium and so on).
(3) Media costs for cultivated meat are still estimates
Humbird's figures are estimates for a hypothetical scale of 100,000 tonnes a yearNot yet confirmed. Within the scope of this article, no primary source could be confirmed showing what media actually cost in commercial production.
(4) Original papers whose full text could not be checked
For the original papers from the 1950s to the 1970s (Eagle, Dulbecco, Ham, Moore, Stanners, Morgan, Leibovitz), the bibliographic details were checked on PubMed, but the full texts could not be read for this article. Target cells and formulation features follow the description in a peer-reviewed review (Yao and Asayama 2017).
- A medium is a basal medium plus additives chosen for the purpose. Many basal media were created between 1950 and 1980 for particular cellsSourced
- Serum is being phased down because of lot variation, infectious agents and the purification burden. The EMA sets out controls for the quality and viral safety of bovine serum in a guidelineSourced
- E8 medium showed that human iPS cells can be cultured by adding just seven components to a basal mediumSourced
- Albumin was partly working as an “adsorbent” that binds lipids and impuritiesSourced
- Feed media add poorly soluble tyrosine and fragile glutamine in peptide formSourced
- Sterile filtration (0.2 µm) is not aimed at virusesSourced
- In the cultivated meat estimate, amino acids make up about 51% of the costOur calculation. Whether it can work as a food remains unconfirmedNot yet confirmed
15. Glossary
- Culture medium
- The liquid (or solid) used to grow cells outside the body. This article deals with liquid media.
- Basal medium
- The foundation of a medium, made of inorganic salts, sugar, amino acids, vitamins, a buffer and so on.
- Fetal bovine serum (FBS)
- Serum obtained from the blood of bovine fetuses. Rich in growth factors and more, but undefined in composition.
- Serum-free medium
- A medium with no serum added. Factors such as insulin are added individually instead.
- Chemically defined medium
- A medium in which every component and its concentration are specified.
- Xeno-free
- Using no components derived from animals other than humans when culturing human cells.
- ITS
- Insulin, transferrin and selenium. The standard trio of additives in serum-free media.
- CHO cells
- Cells derived from Chinese hamster ovary. Widely used to produce antibody drugs.
- HEK293 cells
- Cells derived from human embryonic kidney. Used to produce viral vectors.
- Fed-batch culture
- A mode in which concentrated nutrients are added during the run.
- Perfusion culture
- A mode in which the medium is replaced continuously while the cells are retained.
- Bicarbonate buffer system
- Holds the pH through the equilibrium between sodium hydrogen carbonate and CO2 in the gas phase.
- HEPES
- One of the buffers developed for biological research. Helps hold the pH even without CO2.
- Phenol red
- The pH indicator in media. A weak oestrogenic effect has been reported.
- Organoid
- A small organ-like structure that forms by self-organisation from stem cells.
- Sterile filtration
- Making a liquid sterile without heat, using a filter that holds back microorganisms.
16. References (primary sources)
- Eagle H. “Nutrition needs of mammalian cells in tissue culture”, Science 122:501 (1955) — doi.org
- Eagle H. “Amino acid metabolism in mammalian cell cultures”, Science 130:432 (1959) — doi.org
- Dulbecco R, Freeman G. “Plaque production by the polyoma virus”, Virology 8:396 (1959) — doi.org
- Ham RG. “Clonal growth of mammalian cells in a chemically defined, synthetic medium”, PNAS 53:288 (1965) — doi.org
- Moore GE, Gerner RE, Franklin HA. “Culture of normal human leukocytes”, JAMA 199:519 (1967) (PubMed) — pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Stanners CP, Eliceiri GL, Green H. “Two types of ribosome in mouse-hamster hybrid cells”, Nature New Biology 230:52 (1971) — doi.org
- Iscove NN, Melchers F. “Complete replacement of serum by albumin, transferrin, and soybean lipid in cultures of lipopolysaccharide-reactive B lymphocytes”, J Exp Med 147:923 (1978) — doi.org
- Barnes D, Sato G. “Methods for growth of cultured cells in serum-free medium”, Anal Biochem 102:255 (1980) — doi.org
- Yao T, Asayama Y. “Animal-cell culture media: History, characteristics, and current issues”, Reprod Med Biol 16:99 (2017) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Morgan JF, Morton HJ, Parker RC. “Nutrition of animal cells in tissue culture; initial studies on a synthetic medium”, Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 73:1 (1950) — doi.org
- Leibovitz A. “The growth and maintenance of tissue-cell cultures in free gas exchange with the atmosphere”, Am J Hyg 78:173 (1963) — doi.org
- van der Valk J et al. “Fetal Bovine Serum (FBS): Past – Present – Future”, ALTEX 35:99 (2018) — doi.org
- European Medicines Agency (EMA) “Guideline on the use of bovine serum in the manufacture of human biological medicinal products”, EMA/CHMP/BWP/457920/2012 rev 1 (PDF) — ema.europa.eu
- Chen G et al. “Chemically defined conditions for human iPSC derivation and culture”, Nat Methods 8:424 (2011) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Ludwig TE et al. “Derivation of human embryonic stem cells in defined conditions”, Nat Biotechnol 24:185 (2006) — doi.org
- Ludwig TE et al. “Feeder-independent culture of human embryonic stem cells”, Nat Methods 3:637 (2006) — doi.org
- STEMCELL Technologies “mTeSR™1” product page — stemcell.com
- Nakagawa M et al. (Kyoto University CiRA and others) “A novel efficient feeder-free culture system for the derivation of human induced pluripotent stem cells”, Sci Rep 4:3594 (2014) — doi.org
- Ritacco FV, Wu Y, Khetan A. “Cell culture media for recombinant protein expression in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells: History, key components, and optimization strategies”, Biotechnol Prog 34:1407 (2018) — doi.org
- Kishishita S et al. (Chugai Pharmaceutical and others) “Optimization of chemically defined feed media for monoclonal antibody production in Chinese hamster ovary cells”, J Biosci Bioeng 120:78 (2015) — doi.org
- Konstantinov K et al. “The ‘push-to-low’ approach for optimization of high-density perfusion cultures of animal cells”, Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol 101:75 (2006) — doi.org
- Grieger JC, Soltys SM, Samulski RJ. “Production of recombinant adeno-associated virus vectors using suspension HEK293 cells and continuous harvest of vector from the culture media for GMP FIX and FLT1 clinical vector”, Mol Ther 24:287 (2016) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Grace TDC. “Establishment of four strains of cells from insect tissues grown in vitro”, Nature 195:788 (1962) — doi.org
- Vaughn JL et al. “The establishment of two cell lines from the insect Spodoptera frugiperda”, In Vitro 13:213 (1977) — doi.org
- Medvec AR et al. “Improved expansion and in vivo function of patient T cells by a serum-free medium”, Mol Ther Methods Clin Dev 8:65 (2018) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Burridge PW et al. “Chemically defined generation of human cardiomyocytes”, Nat Methods 11:855 (2014) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Brewer GJ et al. “Optimized survival of hippocampal neurons in B27-supplemented Neurobasal, a new serum-free medium combination”, J Neurosci Res 35:567 (1993) — doi.org
- Sato T et al. “Single Lgr5 stem cells build crypt-villus structures in vitro without a mesenchymal niche”, Nature 459:262 (2009) — doi.org
- Boonekamp KE, Dayton TL, Clevers H. “Intestinal organoids as tools for enriching and studying specific and rare cell types”, J Mol Cell Biol 12:562 (2020) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Sato T et al. “Long-term expansion of epithelial organoids from human colon, adenoma, adenocarcinoma, and Barrett's epithelium”, Gastroenterology 141:1762 (2011) — doi.org
- Berthois Y, Katzenellenbogen JA, Katzenellenbogen BS. “Phenol red in tissue culture media is a weak estrogen”, PNAS 83:2496 (1986) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Good NE et al. “Hydrogen ion buffers for biological research”, Biochemistry 5:467 (1966) — doi.org
- US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) “Guidance for Industry: Sterile Drug Products Produced by Aseptic Processing — Current Good Manufacturing Practice”, September 2004 (PDF) — fda.gov
- Humbird D. “Scale-up economics for cultured meat”, Biotechnol Bioeng 118:3239 (2021) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Kuo HH et al. “Negligible-cost and weekend-free chemically defined human iPSC culture”, Stem Cell Reports 14:256 (2020) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Stout AJ et al. “Simple and effective serum-free medium for sustained expansion of bovine satellite cells for cell cultured meat”, Commun Biol 5:466 (2022) (PMC) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- O'Neill EN et al. “Considerations for the development of cost-effective cell culture media for cultivated meat production”, Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 20:686 (2021) — doi.org
17. Claim-to-source audit
| Claim in the text | Basis | Label |
|---|---|---|
| That BME was reported by Eagle in 1955 | Reference 1 https://doi.org/10.1126/science.122.3168.501 | Sourced |
| That MEM was reported by Eagle in 1959 | Reference 2 https://doi.org/10.1126/science.130.3373.432 | Sourced |
| That the original DMEM paper is Dulbecco and Freeman (1959, plaque formation by polyoma virus) | Reference 3 https://doi.org/10.1016/0042-6822(59)90043-1 | Sourced |
| That the original Ham's F-12 paper is Ham (1965, clonal growth in a chemically defined synthetic medium) | Reference 4 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.53.2.288 | Sourced |
| That the original RPMI-1640 paper is Moore et al. (1967, culture of normal human leukocytes) | Reference 5 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4960081/ | Sourced |
| That the original α-MEM paper is Stanners et al. (1971, mouse-hamster hybrid cells) | Reference 6 https://doi.org/10.1038/newbio230052a0 | Sourced |
| That the original form of IMDM (M-DMEM) was a richer version of DMEM with added amino acids, vitamin B12, biotin, selenite, pyruvate and more; that serum could be replaced entirely by albumin, transferrin and soybean lipid; and that the target was mouse B cells responding to lipopolysaccharide | Reference 7 https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.147.3.923 | Sourced |
| That Barnes and Sato (1980) reported methods for culturing cells in serum-free medium | Reference 8 https://doi.org/10.1016/0003-2697(80)90151-7 | Sourced |
| The target cells and features of each basal medium (BME: L cells and HeLa, 13 amino acids and 8 vitamins; MEM: about twice the amino acids; DMEM: about four times, glucose 25 mmol/L and so on; L-15: buffered with phosphate and basic amino acids, pyruvate; F-12: CHO, cited as the world's first chemically defined medium, linoleic acid and putrescine, zinc modification; RPMI: lymphocytes, low Ca and Mg, high phosphate; the components added in α-MEM; 199: chick embryo, complex, organ culture; DMEM/F-12: 50:50, basal medium for serum-free culture). The functions and drawbacks of serum. The components of ITS and B-27. Impurities in albumin and its binding behaviour. Breakdown of glutamine and the dipeptides. Bicarbonate and CO2 (5%, 2% and 10%, with the note that these are theoretical values). Hydrogen peroxide from HEPES under light. The oestrogenic effect of phenol red | Reference 9 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5661806/ | Sourced |
| That the original Medium 199 paper is Morgan et al. (1950) | Reference 10 https://doi.org/10.3181/00379727-73-17557 | Sourced |
| That the original L-15 paper is Leibovitz (1963, culture in free gas exchange with the atmosphere) | Reference 11 https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a120336 | Sourced |
| That FBS raises problems of quality and reproducibility, animal-welfare concerns and cases of fraudulent labelling, and that the development of alternatives and serum-free media is attracting attention | Reference 12 https://doi.org/10.14573/altex.1705101 | Sourced |
| The EMA guideline (adopted 30 May 2013, in effect from 1 December 2013); that it starts from the TSE guidance preferring non-ruminant over ruminant material; that BVDV cannot be completely avoided except in controlled herds or regions and must be tested for before use; and that gamma irradiation is the most commonly used inactivation method | Reference 13 https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/documents/scientific-guideline/guideline-use-bovine-serum-manufacture-human-biological-medicinal-products-revision-1_en.pdf | Sourced |
| The seven E8 components and their concentrations (DMEM/F-12 base; magnesium L-ascorbic acid 2-phosphate 64 mg/L, sodium selenite 14 µg/L, FGF2 100 µg/L, insulin 19.4 mg/L, NaHCO3 543 mg/L, transferrin 10.7 mg/L, TGFβ1 2 µg/L or NODAL 100 µg/L). That leaving out serum albumin was an improvement. That vitronectin is used as the substrate. Lot variation in albumin and its binding of lipids and impurities. Survival without BSA and the link with β-mercaptoethanol. The components of TeSR | Reference 14 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3084903/ | Sourced |
| That Ludwig et al. derived human ES cells under conditions using only recombinant or purified human-derived proteins (2006) | Reference 15 https://doi.org/10.1038/nbt1177 | Sourced |
| The feeder-independent culture paper by Ludwig et al. (2006) | Reference 16 https://doi.org/10.1038/nmeth902 | Sourced |
| That mTeSR™1 is a serum-free cGMP, feeder-free maintenance medium developed under licence to WiCell intellectual property | Reference 17 https://www.stemcell.com/products/mtesr1.html | Sourced |
| That StemFit is a completely xeno-free medium which, combined with the laminin-511 E8 fragment, allowed stable long-term culture with single-cell passaging; and that it came from joint research by CiRA, Osaka University and Ajinomoto | Reference 18 https://doi.org/10.1038/srep03594 | Sourced |
| That CHO media moved to serum-free and chemically defined forms and optimised nutrient supply through fed-batch and perfusion; and that consistency and scalability in preparing powder and liquid media are key issues | Reference 19 https://doi.org/10.1002/btpr.2706 | Sourced |
| That chemically defined media are used for antibody production in CHO cells; that heavily consumed amino acids were added while limiting lactate and ammonia build-up; and that poorly soluble tyrosine was added as dipeptides and tripeptides | Reference 20 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiosc.2014.11.022 | Sourced |
| The introduction of the equivalent specific perfusion rate; that the key is lowering the dilution rate while keeping cell density high; and that push-to-low raised the titre of an anti-TNF antibody several-fold | Reference 21 https://doi.org/10.1007/10_016 | Sourced |
| That adherent HEK293 cells from a clinical master cell bank were adapted to animal-component-free suspension culture to produce AAV; and that choosing a serum-free suspension medium supporting both growth and transfection was one of the optimisation items | Reference 22 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4817810/ | Sourced |
| That Grace reported establishing four cell strains from insect tissue (1962) | Reference 23 https://doi.org/10.1038/195788a0 | Sourced |
| That two lines were established from pupal tissue of Spodoptera frugiperda, IPLB-SF 21 in a haemolymph-supplemented medium and IPLB-SF-1254 in a medium of vertebrate serum and haemolymph | Reference 24 https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02615077 | Sourced |
| That a chemically defined medium was developed that expands all T-cell subsets without human serum; and that in a humanised mouse model the serum-free T cells controlled tumours for longer | Reference 25 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5907749/ | Sourced |
| That a three-component medium of RPMI 1640, L-ascorbic acid 2-phosphate and rice-derived recombinant human albumin gave cardiomyocytes up to 95% TNNT2-positive | Reference 26 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4169698/ | Sourced |
| The report of B27-supplemented Neurobasal as a serum-free medium combination (1993) | Reference 27 https://doi.org/10.1002/jnr.490350513 | Sourced |
| That a single Lgr5-positive stem cell gave rise to an organoid with crypt-villus structures (2009) | Reference 28 https://doi.org/10.1038/nature07935 | Sourced |
| That the culture of Sato et al. (2009) used a cocktail of EGF, Noggin and R-spondin within an extracellular matrix | Reference 29 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7683021/ | Sourced |
| That long-term culture of human small intestine and colon required added Wnt3A plus nicotinamide, an Alk inhibitor and a p38 inhibitor | Reference 30 https://doi.org/10.1053/j.gastro.2011.07.050 | Sourced |
| That phenol red acts as a weak oestrogen at the concentrations found in media (15 to 45 µM) | Reference 31 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC323325/ | Sourced |
| That Good et al. reported hydrogen ion buffers for biological research in 1966 | Reference 32 https://doi.org/10.1021/bi00866a011 | Sourced |
| That B. diminuta (mean diameter 0.3 µm) is the usual challenge organism for 0.2 µm rated filters; that filters are challenged with at least 10⁷ organisms per cm² of effective filtration area; that 0.22 µm and 0.2 µm are interchangeable ratings; that the guidance does not address virus removal; and that the guidance dates from September 2004 | Reference 33 https://www.fda.gov/media/71026/download | Sourced |
| US$37/kg for fed-batch and US$51/kg for perfusion; amino acids US$19/kg, growth factors US$3 to 4/kg and glucose about US$0.24/kg (all at 100,000 tonnes a year, per kg of wet cell mass). The assumed growth-factor concentrations (insulin 19.4, transferrin 10.7, FGF 0.1, TGF-β 0.002 mg/L). The examination of soy hydrolysate for mixed amino acids at US$2/kg | Reference 34 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8362201/ | Sourced |
| The conclusion that the economics of such facilities are likely to stand in the way of an affordable food product | An outlook based on Humbird's estimate, not an actual record. Reference 34 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8362201/ | Not yet confirmed |
| That the reagent cost of B8 is 3% of commercial media, using FGF2, TGFβ3 and neuregulin 1 expressed in E. coli; more than 100 passages; no weekend changes | Reference 35 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7013200/ | Sourced |
| That Beefy-9 is B8 plus recombinant albumin, and expanded bovine satellite cells over seven passages with an average doubling time of 39 hours | Reference 36 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9163123/ | Sourced |
| That therapeutic antibodies sell for orders of magnitude more than meat; and the requirements for cultivated-meat media (food-grade, minimal cost, control of proliferation and differentiation, organoleptic acceptability, free of animal components) | Reference 37 https://doi.org/10.1111/1541-4337.12678 | Sourced |
| A record of low-cost media such as B8 and Beefy-9 being used in volume production of food | Could not be confirmed within the scope of this article; treated as research-stage results | Not yet confirmed |
| 25 mmol/L = about 4.5 g/L; phenol red 15 to 45 µM = about 5.3 to 16 mg/L; the CO2 needed for pH 7.4 (about 5.7%, 3.1% and 9.7%); pH about 7.7 for DMEM at 5% CO2; the E8 concentration ratios (about 270,000 times and 9,700 times); the shares of Humbird's figures (about 51%, about 8 to 11% and about 0.6%) | Our calculation. The molecular weights (glucose 180.16, phenol red 354.4), the Henderson–Hasselbalch coefficients (pKa 6.1, 0.03) and atmospheric pressure of 760 mmHg are assumptions set by this article. Water vapour pressure and temperature correction were ignored | Our calculation |
| That the growth-factor concentrations assumed by Humbird match the E8 formulation | Commentary in which this article cross-checked the figures in References 14 and 34. Whether Humbird explicitly cites E8 as the source was not checked for this article | Commentary |
| NK cell media; the specific compositions of commercial CHO, HEK293 and T-cell media; actual media costs in commercial cultivated-meat production; an official standard that defines terms such as “serum-free” consistently | Not stated in this article because no primary source could be confirmed within its scope | Commentary |
| The content of the full texts of original papers from the 1950s to the 1970s | Bibliographic details were checked on PubMed but the full texts were not read; the text states that target cells and features follow the review in Reference 9 (a note by this article) | Commentary |
| Splitting media into “the base plus what is added”; the three-stage flow of the family tree; the five stages of serum handling; the six-axis overview; reading albumin as an adsorbent; viewing ingredient design as prodrug-style; the parallel with formulation development; reading cultivated meat as the reverse challenge; the readings by purpose | This article's own framing and commentary based on published content. Not views expressed by the institutions or authors | Commentary |
| That Figs. 1, 2, 4, 6 and 7 are explanatory drawings; that Figs. 3, 5 and 9 are drawings that include our calculation; and that the hero image and Fig. 8 are AI-generated images | A note by this article | Commentary |
Last updated 23 September 2026. Sources are limited to primary material (original papers and peer-reviewed reviews, published documents from the EMA and FDA, and companies' own product pages). No market-size or market-share estimates are used. Because the article includes structural readings and materials-design interpretations, those are marked as Commentary and kept separate from sourced fact. NK cell media, the specific compositions of commercial media, actual costs in commercial cultivated-meat production, and an official standard defining media terminology are not covered, because they could not be confirmed in published primary sources. All figures are for explanation. Figs. 1, 2, 4, 6 and 7 are concept diagrams; Figs. 3, 5 and 9 are drawings that include our calculation; the hero image and Fig. 8 are AI-generated images, and none of them shows a real product, piece of equipment or medium. This article explains technology. It is not medical advice and does not recommend any product.